deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

Featured in Groups:

Details

October 23, 2012
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 27
Favourites: 7 [who?]

Views: 18,464 (2 today)
[x]

RD Logo Contest is over!

Journal Entry: Tue Oct 23, 2012, 12:26 AM
Okay everyone! The contest is over! No more time to send your entries!

I'd like to thank you all who took a part of this contest and sent me your lovely designs. I'll now start my judging (and consult two of my good friends) and make my decision. Again, thank you everyone who participated! Below you'll see all the entries we got. One of them will be the new Random Doom logo!

I'll announce the winner.......... Um, soonish. :XD:
(this is a bit busy week for me so I'll see what I can do)

:star:ENTRIES!:star:

:iconpokemon-diamond:::
:iconozzlander: :
:iconepicguitar::
:iconvgk117:: :thumb325521416: , :thumb333766414:
:iconmusegamer::
:iconkakura-gv::
:iconchoco-bit::
:iconneko1inu2kitsune3:: ,
:iconwhimsicottons:: :thumb326221714:
:iconcianid255: : :thumb326489361: , :thumb326577742:
:iconicarusthedragon:: :thumb326581988:
:iconthalateya: :
:iconchombowombo: : ,
:iconrighteouswolf: :
:icongoddess-storm: :
:iconreplisol: :
:icondreamer-believer31: :
:icongothicblueeyes:: : ,
:iconthemadlocust: :
:iconquilaviper: :
:iconsaturngrl: :
:iconi-am-napoleon: :
:icondianamond: :
:icononlymommasboy: :
:iconspeedboosttorchic: :
:icondizzyrin: :
:iconcarrotveggiequeen: :
:iconblackphoenix240: :
:iconjadethemobian: :
:iconbadgerscar01: :
:iconlastdragondreamer: :
:iconteamravers: : ,
:iconskaia200: : :thumb332201783:
:iconthe-walking-dude: :
:iconfenixcast: :
:icontwero:&:iconlooweezah: :
:iconleonpryde: :   
:iconbluewolfren: :

  • Mood: Excited
  • Listening to: Random VG music
  • Watching: Let's Plays
  • Playing: Black2
  • Eating: porridge
  • Drinking: water
Add a Comment:
 
love 0 0 joy 2 2 wow 1 1 mad 1 1 sad 0 0 fear 1 1 neutral 0 0
:icondidijala:
my buddy's half-sister got paid $16513 the prior month. she is getting paid on the laptop and bought a $383600 house. All she did was get blessed and put into action the advice made clear on this web site Cloud65.com
Reply
:iconsuriask:
my neighbor's step-aunt makes $80/hr on the internet. She has been without a job for 6 months but last month her payment was $17416 just working on the internet for a few hours. Here's the site to read more Cloud65.com
Reply
Flagged as Spam
:iconshadownight9:
Mood: Joy ~ShadowNight9 Nov 3, 2012  Student Artist
That great.
Reply
:icondonotdelete:
~DoNotDelete Oct 24, 2012   Digital Artist
I would've been more interested in making you a logo privately - I don't really think you're going to get anything you want through a competition.

Trying to get something like a logo through a competition isn't ideal - especially if you don't have a clear idea about what you want. For the sake of identifying the direction you want the logo to take you need to establish a dialogue with the person who's designing your logo - that way you can have a two-way channel of feedback that gives you the option of identifying logo concepts that you don't like and ones that you do - this informs the designer of the direction to further develop ideas and concepts that will better please you, the client.

Design requires a client/designer feedback loop - asking people to come up with a logo design for you in a 'blind' competition like this was a good way to involve your fans in your work, but also a bad way to get a logo design.

Competitions for the sake of important things like logos only lead toward a situation where you find yourself in a situation of having to settle on an entry that you're less than happy with - which isn't really fair to you or your followers.

I might be completely wrong about this and you may have actually gotten a logo that you do really like through this competition - but I thought I would speak my mind on this point - and I'm still open to a private logo design consultation if you decide you want to go that way.

Kind regards.
Reply
:icontamarinfrog:
*TamarinFrog Oct 24, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
Thanks for being honest.

You are right about that it would be best to do things like these privatively and working with the designer but I chose to keep competition and it's done. At least it was fun.

True, I had to think this a lot before doing this because I was afraid of not getting the results I liked. This is why I gave myself the option to alter and work with the winner. I'm happy to say that there are entries I do like and I am sure I'll be happy with the one I choose.

I appreciate your offer since I love your works but I think it would be really unfair for all these people who took their time and did all these entries if I just suddenly decided that "Nope, I'm not gonna do this!". Or, I would at least have to give everyone something for entering...
Reply
:icondonotdelete:
~DoNotDelete Oct 24, 2012   Digital Artist
Ah, I didn't see that you'd written an alteration clause into your competition guidelines; That sounds like a sensible way to go about it.

I'm glad you've gotten some logo designs that you're more-or-less happy with.
Reply
:icontamarinfrog:
*TamarinFrog Oct 24, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
Yes, this was so that people with no good digital programs such as photoshop and/or illustrator could also take a part. :)
The idea was to see many logo ideas and choose the one I like the best and then keep working on it (if needed) with the creator.

And yes, I already know a few very potential ones I like. :aww:
Reply
:icondonotdelete:
~DoNotDelete Oct 24, 2012   Digital Artist
I'd do it for free btw - I'm not interested in the prizes you've offered up here.
Reply
:iconpokediginut:
~pokediginut Oct 23, 2012  Student Writer
Have fun picking ^^
Reply
Add a Comment: